The WhoNA Episode Voting Statistics

Well I got bored and so I added up all of the poll votes thus far for the series 6 part one episodes that have been aired. Here we can decipher how much the WhoNA Voters (that sounds so cool ) like or dislike series 6 part one, and I'll use this thread to do the same for future episodes.

And so the stats so far look like this:

Series 6 Part One (Impossible Astronaut - The Rebel Flesh)

Fantastic = 81 Votes
Good =14 Votes
Okay = 56 Votes
Bad = 2 Votes
Terrible = 12 Votes

So far, then, series 6 has been 'fantastic'. Now if I can just find all the other threads from series 5 then I'll add up the poll votes from them and we can compare.

And yes, I am bored LOL

Oh, maybe not, seems half of the topics from S5 have gone missing. I think threads are automatically deleted after 30 days of inactiveness if I remember rightly.

Ah well, at least we'll be able to compare to series 6 part 2 and series 7 part 1 and so on, so forth.

Just need to look a little harder, Scary! All of the S5 polls are still here.

Fantastic = 196 Votes
Good = 160 Votes
Okay = 89 Votes
Bad = 36 Votes
Terrible = 18 Votes

There you go. I even did the math for ya.

Though I don't take too much stock in these numbers. People tend to rate an episode higher right after it airs. If we did the polls now for each S5 episode, I bet the numbers would be different. Not my votes, though. I'd still rate almost every episode "terrible"!

Oh, and for the record, the highest rated S5 episode was "Vincent and the Doctor" and the lowest was "The Big Bang".

rdks wrote:

Just need to look a little harder, Scary! All of the S5 polls are still here.

Fantastic = 196 Votes
Good = 160 Votes
Okay = 89 Votes
Bad = 36 Votes
Terrible = 18 Votes

There you go. I even did the math for ya.

Though I don't take too much stock in these numbers. People tend to rate an episode higher right after it airs. If we did the polls now for each S5 episode, I bet the numbers would be different. Not my votes, though. I'd still rate almost every episode "terrible"!

Oh thanks mate! I must admit I just searched "S5E1" at the top of the index page, nothing came up so I assumed we'd lost all of the threads. Guess I should have actually gone through the pages of this section.


And seems as you gave us best episodes (which I never thought of!), unsuprisingly '"The Doctor's Wife" has so far been the best episode and, again unsurprisngly, "The Rebel Flesh" has so far been voted the worst.

Wait, we had "Good" last year? And isn't that relatively new to this year's polls? Wes is confused!

Wes Crayon wrote:

Wait, we had "Good" last year? And isn't that relatively new to this year's polls? Wes is confused!

Yeah we did have 'Good' last year but I sort of forgot about it this year. I tend to rush online and make the thread before someone else does and I rush the polls...

But I guess this sort of makes the stats unreliable. Unless we just add the Good to the Fantastic and the Bad to the Terrible?

really doesn't surprise me which episodes were gold, and which were just rubbish.